Asteroids, comets and meteors
- Builds on
- Sections 2.5, 3.2, 3.9 and 6.3
- Reading time
- 35 min
- Exercises
- 3
- Olympiad problems
- 1
Every year around 12 August the Perseid meteors streak across the night sky, up to about a hundred an hour from a dark site, all seeming to fly out of one small patch of sky in Perseus. They are grains of dust shed by the comet Swift–Tuttle, which crosses Earth's orbit once every 133 years, and Earth ploughs through its trail at the same point of its orbit each August. Comets, asteroids and the dust and rock they leave behind are the small bodies of the Solar System. They are too small to be planets, but they record how the planets formed, and olympiad problems use them to test orbits, brightness and the geometry of the sky.
6.6.1Asteroids
Two asteroids have the same absolute magnitude, but one reflects 5% of the light falling on it and the other 25%. How do their sizes compare?
Most asteroids, small rocky or metallic bodies, go round the Sun between Mars and Jupiter, from about 2.1 au to 3.3 au, in the main belt. The largest, Ceres, is about 940 km across, and most are much smaller. The belt is not evenly filled. At certain distances there are almost no asteroids, the Kirkwood gaps. They lie where an asteroid's period would be a simple fraction of Jupiter's period of 11.87 years. An asteroid there meets Jupiter at the same points of its orbit again and again, and the repeated tugs build up until its orbit is changed, much as a swing goes higher when it is pushed at the same point of each swing.
By Kepler's third law (3.2), an asteroid that goes round
An asteroid is usually too small to show a disc, so its size has to come from its brightness. In Section 6.3 we found that the absolute magnitude fixes the product of the albedo and the square of the radius. Writing it for the diameter
| the diameter of the asteroid | |
| its geometric albedo | |
| its absolute magnitude |
Ceres has an absolute magnitude of 3.34 and a geometric albedo of 0.09. How large is it?
By (6.14),
A near-Earth asteroid has
6.6.2Comets
A comet is a body of ice and dust a few kilometres across, its nucleus. Far from the Sun it is frozen and dark. Within about 3 au of the Sun, where the sunlight is more than a ninth as strong as at Earth, the water ice begins to turn straight to gas. The gas and the dust it carries swell into a glowing cloud around the nucleus, the coma, which can be wider than the Sun.
Two forces then pull the coma out into tails. The gas is ionised by sunlight and swept away by the solar wind, so the ion tail points straight away from the Sun, whatever the direction the comet is moving. The dust is pushed outwards more gently by the pressure of sunlight, and it lags behind along the orbit, so the dust tail curves. On the way out from the Sun, a comet travels tail first.
Comets come from two great reservoirs. Short-period comets, with periods of less than 200 years, mostly come from the Kuiper belt, a ring of icy bodies beyond Neptune, from about 30 au to 50 au. Long-period comets fall in from the Oort cloud, a vast shell tens of thousands of au across, and many visit the inner Solar System only once (Section 3.4). Halley's comet has an orbit with
| Distance from the Sun | |
|---|---|
| Speed | |
| Tails | |
| Orbit |
Comet Encke, with a period of 3.30 years, swings from 0.34 au to 4.09 au and moves at 69.8 km/s at perihelion. Running it shows the comet spending most of its time far out and slow, then rushing round the Sun in a few weeks with its tails swinging round to stay pointed away from the Sun.
A comet has a period of 6 years and comes to within 1 au of the Sun. How far out does it go?
6.6.3Meteors
A meteoroid is a grain or rock in space. When one hits the upper air, at around 100 km height, friction heats it and the air around it until both glow, and we see a meteor. Most are grains smaller than a grain of sand, but they arrive so fast that a single gram at 60 km/s carries
How fast a meteoroid can strike follows from energy. The slowest arrive at Earth's escape speed, 11.2 km/s, because even a body at rest near Earth falls in at that speed. The fastest are on orbits just bound to the Sun, which at 1 au move at the Sun's escape speed there,
| the speed at which the meteoroid reaches the top of the atmosphere | |
| its speed relative to Earth before Earth's gravity pulls it in | |
| Earth's escape speed, 11.2 km/s |
In the evening we are on the side of Earth facing backwards along its orbit, and only meteoroids that catch us up can reach us. After midnight we face forwards and sweep up meteoroids from ahead, like the front windscreen of a car in rain, so more meteors are seen before dawn, and faster ones.
The meteoroids of a meteor shower come from a comet's trail and move on nearly parallel paths. Parallel lines seen in perspective seem to spread out from one point, as railway tracks seem to meet in the distance, so the meteors of a shower appear to fly away from one point of the sky, the radiant. The shower is named after the constellation of its radiant, such as Perseus for the Perseids. Since each meteor moves along a great circle away from the radiant, tracing two meteor trails backwards until they cross finds the radiant.
Find the fastest speed at which a meteoroid can strike Earth's air. Take Earth's orbital speed as 29.78 km/s and its escape speed as 11.19 km/s.
The fastest meteoroid moves at the Sun's escape speed at 1 au,
- A comet's tail does not stream out behind it like smoke from a train. The ion tail points away from the Sun, so as the comet leaves the Sun it travels tail first.
- The size of an asteroid cannot be found from its magnitude alone. The magnitude fixes only the albedo times the area, so a guess at the albedo is needed, and it can change the size by a factor of two.
- A meteor shower's radiant is not where the meteors are seen most. Meteors can appear anywhere in the sky, and only their trails, traced back, meet at the radiant.
- The Kirkwood gaps are gaps in the distances of asteroids from the Sun, not in their positions on the sky or in space at one moment. Asteroids on eccentric orbits cross the gaps all the time.
- The speed of a meteor is not just its speed round the Sun. What counts is its speed relative to Earth, combined with the speed Earth's gravity adds as it falls in.
- 6.6.1
Where does the 3:1 Kirkwood gap lie, where an asteroid goes round three times for each of Jupiter's turns? Take Jupiter's orbit as 5.2028 au.
auBy Kepler's third law the period goes as , so au. Its period is 3.96 years, a third of Jupiter's 11.87. - 6.6.2
A comet is moving away from the Sun after perihelion. Which way does its ion tail point?
The answer is (c). The solar wind sweeps the ionised gas straight away from the Sun, whatever the comet's motion, so a comet leaving the Sun travels tail first. - 6.6.3
Why are more meteors seen in the hours before dawn than in the evening?
The answer is (a). After midnight we are on the leading side of Earth, so we meet meteoroids head on as well as those catching us up. In the evening only those catching us up can reach us.
2020The radiant of two meteors24 points
Adapted from the 2020 Global e-Competition on Astronomy and Astrophysics (Estonia, online), held in place of the IOAA that year, theory problem 7, parts (b) to (d). We have restated it in our own words and kept the original data. Part (a), the sidereal time, is in Section 2.5. The data put the radiant 14° below the observer's horizon. Meteors can come from below the horizon only if they graze the upper air far away, so a real shower is seen while its radiant is up. The solution was last checked on 23 October 2026.
From Chiayi, Chinese Taipei (latitude 23.5° N), at a local sidereal time of 21h 20m 50s, an observer saw two meteors of the same shower. The first appeared on the horizon due west and ran to a point 15° above the northern horizon. The second began at altitude 23.5° and azimuth 210° and ended at altitude 75° and azimuth 255°. Azimuths are measured from north through east. (b) Find the altitude and azimuth of the radiant. (16 points) (c) Find its right ascension and declination. (6 points) (d) Which of Crux, Dorado, Pavo, Tucana and Triangulum Australe is it closest to? (2 points)
- With
to the north, to the east and up, a point at azimuth and altitude is . The first trail runs from to and the second from to . - The cross product of the two ends of each trail is the pole of its great circle, and the cross product of the two poles points along the line where the great circles cross. Of its two ends, the radiant is the one behind the start of each trail, since the meteors fly away from it.
- This gives the radiant at azimuth 201.9° and altitude −14.0°. The other crossing, at azimuth 21.9°, lies ahead of the meteors and is ruled out.
- By the formulas of Section 1.3, the declination is −67.2° and the hour angle is 4.61 h, so the right ascension is
h, or 16h 44m. - At right ascension 16h 44m and declination −67°, the radiant lies in Triangulum Australe.
Answer(b) Azimuth 201.9°, altitude −14.0°. (c) Right ascension 16h 44m, declination −67.2°. (d) Triangulum Australe.